Thinking of leaving him...ramble

Thinking of leaving him...ramble

stride

Registrant
Hi All,

I apologize in advance for what will probably be a long and rather unfocussed post. I'm tired and feeling foggy-headed. I'm depressed. Still I feel a strong need to "talk" to someone at the moment...someone who can truly understand the general dynamics of my relationship and dilemna.

I feel like giving up (on my relationship). I feel like I've come to the end of the fence and it's time to climb over and beyond it. To move on.
But then again, I am aware that I may feel differently before the day/week/month is through. Still, I always come back to this place...this unsettled place with that disquieting but always there somewhere voice that says, "C'mon, you know what you need to do, Lady. Let go. Face the facts and speak your truth. It's time to invest your energies elsewhere."

Today is one of those very rare days where both my partner and I are home, awake, and have no place that either of us have to be (we work opposite shifts, are on opposite sleep cycles, and usually whatever time we have to spend alone together is taken up with other obligations or compromised by different energy levels, etc). It was an unexpected day off for him that we found out he would have just last night. It is the last such day that we will have for the next 2 weeks.

We haven't had sex for at least a week and I was hoping that this free, lazy day together might mean some cuddling and intimacy before we got up. Usually I'm up hours before he is on days like today (man that guy can sleep!), but today while I was laying kinda half awake and silent beside him thinking he was still asleep, he got up without a word, put some pants on and went into the livingroom to play guitar. Absolutely no crime in that, but it upset me all the same. I got up moments later but he didn't seem to notice at first. When he did, he gave me a sweet and friendly "Good Morning, how are you?"

"Grumpy," says I.

"That's too bad," he said lightly, "Why don't you go back to bed for awhile?"

All innocent enough, but given our history all I got out of it was that, as usual, he wasn't about to ask what I was feeling grumpy about and was hoping I wouldn't volunteer anything. Keep everything light and peachy and life will be okay.
It just pissed me off. Why can't I feel safe to tell him what's bothering me? Why can't I just say, "I'd really like it if..." without it causing problems between us? Hell, why can't I feel safe trying to seduce my own partner, should I feel so inclined? I hate this tacit expectation that if I'm feeling upset (angry, sad, hurt, needy, confused, etc) about anything to do with us/him that I won't show it, mention it and will pretend that all is well.

For him, the unexpected night/day off was an opportunity to get drunk, which is what he did. I don't care for the company of drunks, but in our case it's always a dilemma for me as it's the one time he'll usually talk with me about more personal thoughts and feelings. Anyway, before going to bed last night, we got into a discussion about his desire to move to Ireland next year and his desire to, once there, try n' get custody of his 8 yr old daughter (who lives about 1 1/2 hrs from us here). He's been talking about this for several weeks now, but has never once asked what I want. He has this idea that we should move there, set up house, have his daughter come and live with us (my kids are grown and on their own now) and life will be great. He has family there and is very excited about the idea.

But I have a number of questions, concerns and reservations about this idea--not the least of which is where the money's going to come from for that. Also, while I think his daughter should be his #1 priority, I have come to the realization over the past year that I don't want to be a fulltime parent to any more kids. This last part is a definite shift in attitude for me, one that I struggle with, but I must be--and have been-- honest about it.

Anyway, I fell asleep last night to his accusing me of resenting his daughter, while also arguing that once we're over there my feelings about having her come to live with us fulltime will change. I kept insisting that I do not resent her, that I (having been a single parent and the sole custodian of my own kids for many years) understand all-too-well his concerns for her (living with her Mom, who's a seriously screwed up flake, in both of our opinions) and his interests in having more involvement in her life, etc. Besides, she's a nice kid.

Kid or no kid though, I also tried to explain to him that I feel we have a lot of work to do within our own relationship before I'd feel really comfortable about investing in making such a commitment as moving to Ireland for two years and setting up house there with him. Particularly when it comes to matters of communication, sex, passion and intimacy. I wasn't surprised when his only real response to that was that sometimes a move to a new place--somewhere he wants to be--can make all the difference in the world with such things. That and the fact that he "knows" I'd love it there, which oughtta be reason enough to go. Besides, he says, if I found I didn't want to stay there, I could always take off on my own "to Greece or something for six months" and come back when I wanted to. Huh???

Sorry, but I'm a firm believer that "wherever you go, there you are," and I don't believe for one moment that our moving to Ireland would magically dissolve the problems we have with sex, intimacy, and communication.

He's also mentioned his desire to marry me several times in the past many months. My response has always been "let's give it another 5 years and see if we can work through some of our problems first [primarily re: intimacy, communication, sex]." Anyway, I brought that up at some point this morning and he said something to the effect of "What? I don't remember saying I wanted to get married. If I did, you shouldn't read so much into it...I was probably just talking. I know that that decision would be up to you anyway." He also said, as he so often does, that I "take things [he says] too literally." Something he generally says with great impatience, exasperation and not a little condescension.

I was floored. After telling me on a number of occasions, some very recently, of his desire to marry me (he's almost 44 and has never been married), here he was denying having done so or, if he had, trying to minimize that as if it wasn't anything I should have paid any real attention to. Not only that but when challenged on it, he tried to dump it into my lap as if such possibilities and prospects are entirely my responsibility or something. Almost as if he was saying that if I ever did want to marry him, he'd marry me because that's what I wanted.

I just sat there for several minutes while he reclined on the couch, a pleasant, relaxed looking smile on his face (as if the conversation we'd begun could've been about the weather or casual dinner plans or something), and was soon back asleep (which he is still).

I dunno. I'm probably not communicating too clearly here and those things related above are only just fragmented pieces of the story. Hell, just yesterday I was asking him, quite gently but clearly, to leave (move out), after listening to him angrily tell me that I'm "too sensitive," "think too much," and that my desire for more indication from him that he finds me desirable, attractive, etc is "just creepy" and that he's "not going to feed into that." He kept saying, as I've heard countless times before over the past 3 1/2 years, that he doesn't understand me and wasn't going to bother with what, essentially, he sees as my neuroses...that basically I was wasting his time and what could have otherwise been a perfectly good day and should just 'get a grip.' You know, like I am the problem, and he hasn't got time for this crap.

When I pointed out the fact that while his problems with personal communication and intimacy/sex are quite foreign to me, I have always tried very hard to be sensitive and understanding of that, not put him down or negated him for those things, etc, he said "You have a point there," and we ended up having a 10 or 15 minute talk about some of our issues, agreeing to continue to work on them together. The rest of the day went well, but now I feel (and without surprise) like we're right back to square one again.

"Square one" is that place where for so long as I don't show or talk about my feelings/needs and just go gayly through the day as if all is well, everything will be fine. "The Great Pretend," as I call it. As I've pointed out to him on various occasions, I think this is quite a natural, comfortable (anesthetized) place for him, given that he grew up in a home where Daddy routinely sexually abused all 3 of his boys and nobody talked about it...everybody pretending that life was "normal" and all was well (as they still do). But, in my view anyway, this is hardly a healthy or productive way to go through life. And I, for one, won't do it.

I've just been trying to "keep the faith" for so f***ing long now, clinging to whatever signs of growth/change/hope there has been in our relationship--and there have been some--but my faith and willingness to hang in there is fading fast. I don't feel any faith right now. I don't feel at all hopeful right now. And while he will argue that I am self-absorbed, should "just lighten up," etc, my take on things is that it's all about him. His comfort zones. His rights to "space" and privacy. His dreams and desires. His sexual baggage. Etc, etc. I need more mutuality than this...something he says "isn't natural" to him (to be more thoughtful and considerate in his day-to-day interactions with me in a way that is meaningful to me).

Not that he's an asshole. He isn't. He's gentle and, on the surface, laid-back. He's got an easy sense of humour, likes to laugh, and is pretty affectionate most of the time, though in an almost filial way. And to the best of his ability and understanding, I know he loves me deeply. Hard to convey here, but please take my word for it.

Still, I can't escape the fact that for the 5 months we were split up last year, I felt so much better about my life in general. I had more energy, was healthier, looked better, loved my apartment, had more money, had a much more active social life, and was looking forward to my future.

I love this man. I do. But I love myself too. Am I completely out-to-lunch to want a partner who is as concerned and considerate of my needs, feelings and dreams as he is of his own?

Ah, enough already. Thanks for letting me spill for awhile.

Stride
 
Post script...

Man, the silence around here over the past 24 hours has been pregnant and heavy! It was a gorgeous spring day here yesterday and after posting the above, I decided to have a shower and go for a walk. My guy got up at about 5 pm, just as I was leaving, wanting to know where I was going and, when I told him ("for a walk"), said "Okay" as he began running a bath for himself.

Anyway, I called him about an hour later to let him know where I was and that I was resuming my walk along the waterfront. He asked, very sweetly, if I'd like him to join me. As gently as I could, I declined that suggestion and came home about an hour later. He made a number of efforts to smile at, touch, and talk to me (just casual conversation, nothing personal), but beyond briefly and politely answering his questions I could not bring myself to respond in kind. I said nothing when he came to bed and very little to him this morning when he was heading off to work.

I am not trying to "punish" him, hurt him, start a fight or any other such thing. My current (and very obvious) withdrawal from him comes from my not knowing what else to do right now. I know he doesn't want any more "talks"--he hates them--and they invariably result in still more conflict and frustration--at least initially--no matter what I say or how I say it, it seems. I'm too tired for that myself...tired of the endless merry-go-round that doesn't seem to go anywhere in the long run. Tired of repeating myself. Tired of his insistence that I keep what I have to say to a sentence or two at most, if I "must talk". Tired of not feeling safe to be who I am, feel what I feel, need what I need, etc, without feeling like it's all such an imposition and unwelcome annoyance/burden for him.

He would've gone for a walk with me last night. Maybe we would even had "made love" at some point. Perhaps he views my disinclination to enjoin his company last night as frustrating and confusing at best; I mean, isn't spending more such time together what I'm always saying I want?

Well, yes it is. But not like that. Not when it involves my compliance in pretending I'm not upset when I am and in keeping silent about things weighing heavily on my mind that concern us.

Funny, but when I got home last night he was watching Metallica's "Monster" film and I (sitting on the opposite end of the couch) watched the last half of it with him. It's a documentary about the two years the group spent working with a therapist on their interpersonal issues as a group, etc. When I commented at the end on how impressed I was with them for committing to such a project, etc, he said he was too, adding that if I'd watched it from the beginning the positive growth of each player and the group as a whole would've been especially palable. All I could think of was: "How is it that he can recognize how positive and valuable open, honest and on-going communication has been for them--and the guidance of a therapist--but not see how the same could be true for us?

Oh sigh. Must get to work now.

Stride
 
Sometimes I kinda know what I want to do, or maybe should do. But I have doubts that I can do.
And by the time I've figured it out, the moment has passed.

Dave :(
 
Hi Dave,

Sorry to be a pain, but would you mind elaborating on what you mean (what exactly in my post you're referring to)? I'm not sure I understand your response.

Merci,

Stride
 
Lloydy
Isn't it a general problem with men ?
Is it a problem of time to sort out a problem or of a prejudice men generally have about pride ?
I am just wondering if men do not tend to bring into their relationship the "win-lose" dynamic they have in their professional lives, and a dynamic learnt at a very early age. I have been observering men for years and it's struck me many times that it was really important for them to feel they "won" over an argument. So making concessions in a relationship could be view by male pride as "losing". I guess as a woman I just want to feel heard and cherished. I used to be a controling freak in the relationship and I was in a win-lose state of mind. Today I feel it is more important to make "us" work within a natural rythm based on love and respect.
I would be very interested to hear men's point of view here ! :)
 
Caro,

Isn't it a general problem with men ?
Speaking for myself only, I think it's VERY important--particularly in a forum such as this--that we choose our words carefully and try to avoid any inference that given individuals and/or set groups are the "problem." I appreciate that you may just be trying to understand what might lay behind our partners' apparent reticence to talk and/or own responsibility for the words they say and, regardless, am sure you meant no offense. Still, just as if someone were to open a post with "Isn't it a general problem with women," I have concerns that the posing of such a question in that way sets the wrong tone here.

Is it a problem of time to sort out a problem or of a prejudice men generally have about pride ? I am just wondering if men do not tend to bring into their relationship the "win-lose" dynamic they have in their professional lives, and a dynamic learnt at a very early age. I have been observering men for years and it's struck me many times that it was really important for them to feel they "won" over an argument.
In my experience, most of us--male or female--attach feelings of importance to feeling that we're "right" or have "won," whether in the professional realm or the more personal. I think that people tend to be defensive/protective of their egos, perhaps especially in their most personal relationships. And if women sometimes seem more willing to surrender ("sacrifice"?) their stake in such things in the hope of re-establishing peace in their relationships, I am not convinced that this is necessarily true if one looks at things more closely. Nor do I believe that this is any more healthy of a response in many cases. But if we're going to stereotype here, I would say that yes, there's a great deal of culturally engrained behavioural responses to how the two sexes tend to respond/react to interpersonal conflicts. Worthy considerations when seeking to understand what's really going on for our partners in such situations, but as soon as we start getting into that "us v. them" mindset, however subconsciously or subtly, I think the prospects for enhanced understanding and greater closeness are diminished. Am I making sense here?


So making concessions in a relationship could be view by male pride as "losing".
One could say I feel that to become willing to pretend to feelings I don't have in, for example, situations such as those I've described in the preceding posts would be akin to his having "won" and my having "lost," but that's not it. (Hell, we both "lose" in such a case.) In my partner's case at least, I don't think it's so much about "winning" as it is about say fear, denial, and/or feelings of inadequacy. I absolutely know that he wants very much for things to be good between us and for me to be happy. For whatever pride is involved here, I perceive that as an unconscious mask for fear.

I guess as a woman I just want to feel heard and cherished.
Yes. And I will concede that, typically anyway, we women tend to get those feelings (feeling heard and cherished) from feeling that our partner is actively listening to and seeking to understand us when we feel the need to talk. I also think that men too, want to feel understood, accepted and cherished, but tend to get those feelings affirmed through other means in the relationship.

Typically, women want to talk through their feelings and problems when they arise--often at length and in detail (much to many a man's chagrin)--while it seems to me that men would rather mull things over in isolation until they feel they've identified "the bottom line" (the crux of the problem) which they may then choose to deliver if they don't simply try to resolve it on their own without outward comment. John Gray's "Men, Women and Relationships" is a wonderful exploration of these concepts/issues.

Anyway, what I'm after is greater understanding and closeness/connection between my partner and I. Thus, I try to avoid donning prejudicial lenses about where he's coming from; to respect that we are different people, but with a shared interest (love, safety, connection, etc); and to "have the serenity to accept the things I cannot change and the courage to change the things I can."

Hope I'm making sense here?

Stride
 
Dear Stride

I did not refer here to "stereotypes", and I used the word problem not in the sense of that being THE problem but one of many affecting communication in a relationship. I did not refer it to the specific of male survivors either but simply referring to what society teaches us. As women, I believe we are programmed to be sympathetic, patient and also we are asked to serve others. Men are asked to perform, achieve be agressive and compete.
I am against this sexist division but nevertheless it does exist and can have a huge impact on the way it affects relationships, or on the way men and women approach relationship. I was just raising a question to offer a new perspective on the issue, it was by no mean a jugement on your current situation or on men in general.
 
Stride
I read your first two posts here, and felt such strong feelings of recognition that I it shook me rigid, I was in tears.

When I said "Sometimes I kinda know what I want to do, or maybe should do. But I have doubts that I can do.
And by the time I've figured it out, the moment has passed."
I was relating strongly to what you are seeing in your husband, I ( we ) "talk the talk", but somehow can't find the way to carry it through everytime.

Yes, we might well know what the reasons for our behaviour are, we know what we ( possibly ) need to do more to get out of our old behaviours, but we still don't feel that we can do it. Some lingering doubts remain that tell me ( us ) that I'm not quite ready. "maybe tomorrow I'll do it" I tell myself. Tomorrow never comes.

A lot of this is what Caro writes about, the old and outdated stereotypes that still affect us. Maybe this is more of a problem to people of a 'certain age' - although Caro is a lot younger than me and she recognises it. But a lot of these stereotypes are cultural and very deep rooted.

So I still find it hard to say "I'm having a bad day here" because the old macho pride won't allow me to. When I have said this to my wife she responds in every way I could ever wish for, so I have a reference point. Why can't I rely on that?
Again it's the macho thing, I'm 'supposed to care for my wife' - so I back off because I don't want to add to her troubles. Which is bullshit, because if I'm feeling bad then she's gonna suffer!

So I get locked into the cycle of 'doing ok' - on the face of it - when what I should be doing is dealing with every little problem as it arises WITH her.
I can see this, I often see it as it happens now. But once the 'moment' has passed I also treat it as being too late. My wife has learned to recognise this behaviour now and challenges me when she sees it happening, which I welcome.

I recognise that for myself I need to be challenged, my therapist did it, my group therapy certainly does it. So I don't mind my wife and friends doing it either.
By being challenged I think about MY actions and behaviours, then I talk about them with whoever has challenged me, and eventually I find a way within myself to realign my thinking and escape the dysfunctional behaviours.
If I'm left alone I take the easy route, I'm a lazy bastard by nature, and the easy option is to do as little as I need to to get by. It's not what I want to do, but at 51yo I have over 35 years of distorted thinking to overcome.

Perhap's I'm someone who needed challenging all along, and maybe would have needed it without the abuse? All of the things that I have achieved such as rebuilding our old cottage from a ruin and building my competition 4x4's have always been done under either pressure, or as a challenge. Some nights when I was supposedly working on the cottage I went to the pub instead. Why? because it was easier than plastering walls for a start, but because nobody was there on that particular night to give me a bit of a push is the main reason. And I'm still the same, there's a muddy hole in the garden where a pond is going, I dug the hole 6 years ago.

I've always said that nobody can drag us kicking and screaming into therapy and through our healing, I firmly believe that. But I am also a huge believer in the fact that those of us who are lucky enough to have someone in our lives that has an interest in our recovery are in a better position than those who are on their own.
Nobody can do our healing for us, and pressure will often make us do the opposite thing, but present us with a challenge and that's entirely different, perhaps this is the good side of the macho stereotype and something that can be exploited ?
Pressure is seen as 'abusive' - it's seen as a one way deal. "you must do this because ...." piles everything on to us, and if we're in a relationship then we want to see that relationship at work as well.
If I'm challenged by my wife I see that relationship at work. To be challenged tells me that she wants me to respond to her views, not obey her orders.

That's some kind of tightrope to walk, and I have so much admiration for my wife who very rarely falls off her rope, it's usually under huge provocation from me :rolleyes:
I don't get off lightly, she makes me think about what I'm doing - or more usually not doing - and expects a response from me.

I also believe that we as survivors have to expect some 'grief' from our partners and friends.
This is something I rarely mention here for various reasons, but I think we have a responsibilty to get back to life in the real world. We should get off our butts and make some genuine efforts.
Many survivors do just that, but I also see a few that are still expecting to get 'something for nothing' - that ain't ever going to happen. Living in a perpetual 'pity party' isn't an option I'm afraid.
That might be an contraversial view, and I do recognise that a survivor in the earlier stages of recovery will often appear to be that way, but after a few years of therapy and some personal work MOST survivors SHOULD be accepting their own personal challenges, indeed setting them, and accepting the challenges of others.

If we desire 'normality' then we have to seek it out, it isn't going to fall into our laps.
Instead of letting the moment slip past we have to seize it.

Dave
 
I'm on a roll here...

I read a great deal, always have done. My wife jokes that I'll read the phone book if nothing else is available.

Many years ago my wife had a very good career in the UK Civil Service who trained their staff very well, so she would go on all these different management courses and get all the books by the guru of the day such as Demming. Which she never read but I did.

I learned a lot from reading these books, and often her course notes as well. I created havoc at work in team meetings when I tried to out-manage our managers, who had zero training.
But the main thing I picked up was the various methods of persuading people to do things for you.

These methods are what my wife uses naturally anyway, but she's had them honed to near perfection at our taxpayers expense :D
Most of these management guru's use basic psychological process' that they re-package to their own style, but the basics always come down to a basic thing.
Making what you want attractive to the other person.

And the best way to do that is by involving the other person, "challenging".
Which manager is best to work for, one who shouts orders or the one who gives you some responsibilty and involvement?

Dave
 
Dave,

Thanks for the clarification (and yeh, my guy's got a few muddy holes that've been laying around here for quite a while too! To be fair though, so do I :o )

Thought I'd let you know that after reading your two posts of elaboration yesterday, I decided to take the liberty of printing them out (hope that's okay!), along with the second of my first two posts in this thread. Then, before going to work last night, I left them out with a note asking my guy to please read when he got home. If nothing else, I thought it might help him understand my recent and continued silence and withdrawal. That, and for him to see some replies from someone he might feel understood him.

Well, he popped in to my workplace last evening, as smiley and sweet as usual, and said nothing of the "note" I'd left him. I finally asked if he'd read it and he said he had. His only comments were that he's "just a do-it-yourself kind of guy" (meaning he's not the kind to join the MS forum or talk to anyone about his issues), and that you (Dave) had to have somethin' goin' on "cos' he's living in the UK and into 4X'ing." (My guy drives a '74 LandCruiser; at least, when it'll run! :rolleyes: )

He did not ask or suggest that we talk about anything, but did say he is aware that I'm very close to leaving him, so if my participation in this forum is keeping me from doing so then "spend as much time on the computer as you want!" When he left, still all smiles, kisses and affection, I said "We still have to talk." Don't recall him saying much to that either way.

I don't think he would agree that he's "getting something for nothing" or that he doesn't 'live in the real world', but for the most part I see it that way. What remains unclear to me is how to determine what's "pressuring" him and what's "challenging" him. I'm certainly quite familiar with the management/sales techniques you describe--was a group home manager for years myself and have read those books too. Regardless, right now I'm feeling that I don't care much one way or the other what happens. At the moment, the only thing keeping me from asking him to move out is the fact that I still melt inside just to see his smile...a power not to be underestimated, but also a power that will surely fade if things don't change more around here. And I'm sure fed up with always being the one to push for that.

Stride
 
"just a do-it-yourself kind of guy"
So was I, for far too long. And all I ever did was try the same 'cure' for the same old problems, and the surprising thing is that when they didn't work the first time I kept right on trying. And a great many other survivors I know did the same thing.

It was only therapy that got me thinking outside my usual ( old ) box, and I honestly don't think that I could have changed as much as I have without therapy.
Just recognizing that I was an abuse victim and talking to my wife about it wouldn't have done any good. Because she knows me so well, and loves me, she would never have been able to be completely objective. She would quite possibly refrain from poking me with a pointy stick in the way my therapist did. It's one thing to mention something, it's a giant leap into the unknown to describe exactly how you feel about that thing.
And there are still things that I wouldn't say to my wife.

But as always, the decision to ask for the right sort of help will always lay with the survivor, not that it should prevent you from discussing his getting help - laying down a challenge.

And a Cruiser driver should relish a challenge.
I have a 87 that's about to lose it's roof and all the other unwanted stuff so I can seriously off-road it.
That's my hobby, my release, and I'm sure my sanity. I learn to trust my judgement, not only about how much grip is left before I roll, but my trust in other people, the guys I sometimes ride with, the way the club is run and my role on the committee, who can I trust to make sure the next event takes place? All that interaction has helped me, I've learned from some mistakes, but I've gone from someone who couldn't be bothered to do virtually anything 10 years ago to someone who thinks nothing of driving a 200 mile round trip after work to get something done so that we can go out and enjoy ourselves. I don't do it for 'praise' from others, I do it because I can - so I do.

It's an attitude, and one that I've learned through therapy. If I sat there and said "I don't think I can do that" I was met with a stony silence, and I had to sit and think about my answer. I knew that he wanted me to explain "why" - and invariably I had no good reason, so after the silence I would say "I think I can try this". Then he'd unlock the door and let me go home. ;)

I like my new attitude, I used to view people with this sort of 'can do' attitude as jerks, and I would react against them, which looking back never did me any favours.
But now, having that attitude, I see that the people I respect have no issue with this attitude, in fact I think they like it, and the people that rebel against it? ask me how much I care?

Dave
 
Back
Top