Peter and Kurt,
Last year I started a post on virginity in which I was addressing adult survivors who felt embarrassed because they were still virgins. There was a good discussion, and among us adults it was more or less assumed that the abuse as boys did not count.
But among the teens on the site back then this was no good answer at all! I got PMs saying wait a minute, what about us! Are we still virgins or what? We did this and we did that, etc. All of them, like you two, really hated the idea that abuse when they were younger meant, as you put it so well Peter, "Bye bye virginity". One in particular was especially devastated because the first time he ejaculated was with an abuser. His reaction, if I quote him correctly, was, "That's so fucking disgusting, I just want to cry every time I think about it." In my own case, I remember my father coming into my room and giving me "the talk" about sex. Problem was that I was already an expert and had done many times all the things he mentioned, plus more that he did NOT mention. I was horrified to hear him talk about sex as something shared with someone you like; I felt like I would choke when he spoke about exploring and learning about sex. When he left I felt like the cheapest whore in the world and I cried through half the night. I just wanted to die and I hated - again - the fact that I was me.
I don't know what a therapist would say to you guys - this is just what I think. Abuse isn't really about sex, although sex is what is done to the boy. If an abuser just wants sex there are plenty of easy ways to get it - he/she doesn't need to abuse a kid. Abuse is about power: the abuser gets off on the idea that his victim is defenseless and at his mercy, and I guess that makes them feel strong and good about themselves.
This may sound like a lot of grownup horseshit, so let me give you an example. Suppose I grab one of you guys off the street, threaten you, and force you to get into my fancy sports car and we drive off at 150 mph. Does that count as your "first ride in a cool fast sports car"? Of course not. It counts as kidnapping and nothing else!
I think it's the same with sex. I really can't see how it "counts" as sex when a confused and frightened boy is raped or otherwise abused. I myself look back at the time I feel I lost my virginity. I was 17, and the girl I was with had been my girlfriend for a year. We had almost "done it" before, when we were both 16, but my grandmother had told me that "fornicators go to hell", so I was scared (yep, I believed her!!!). That time with someone I liked was very special. I was very nervous and so was she, but it was really great. I still consider that this was the time I lost my virginity. I can with all honesty say that the hundred or more times I was abused between the ages of 11 and 14 simply were NOT the same thing as "real sex", if you see what I mean.
I hope this helps, but let me say this is a very important subject - for both of you. Keep asking if you aren't satisfied or still feel funny about this. You might also want to ask your mod buddy Scotty Todd, who is a therapist himself and talks to a lot of teen guys like you. Just remember that if you don't ask, you don't get answers or ideas and the problem or hurt just goes on and on.
Much love,
Larry