Strive -
I understand your concern, and appreciate the support you express - a support that I can clearly read between the lines you have written. I don't know if I can explain this to your satisfaction, but I'll try.
I agree with you that the language I use to describe who I was seems rather unfair to me - to the boy I was. But it speaks to my truth. I don't think it is uncommon for many of us - especially those who survived grooming and the "gentle rapes" to which those seductions led - to blame ourselves. I used to think self-reproach was about poor self-esteem - a natural condition of survivors. I used to think that blaming oneself was due to misguided interpretations about why we did not fight for our bodies, our boundaries, and our nascent sense of honor, to the fact that at the very moment our voices were saying "no," our bodies were inexplicably surrendering and saying "yes." We don't talk much about that, do we? Is there such a thing here as too much honesty?
I look at my intro and realize it was three and a half years since I wrote that. That was how I saw myself then, and frankly my perspectives remain largely unchanged. I was tainted, and I felt that the "good" in my actions were entirely defined within the narrowly focused context of the girls themselves - that by submitting, I spared a few of them them from having to do the same. I was still despicable, but they got a reprieve. They were out swimming or jumping rope for just that one special day. I curl my fingertips to touch my thumb and bring the circle of my hand up to my eye - blocking out everything but the girls. And if I block out all the other crap lapping at the margins of that scene, the moment is perfect. I didn't buy that moment with integrity, wisdom, persuasion, strength or righteous indulgence - it was a solid purchase bought for the price of another disgusting and manipulative submission. That is my truth - and it comes up the same no matter how many coats of pretty paint I cover it with. Maybe the problem isn't in the truth, however. Maybe the problem is in the way we see it.
In these three and a half years, my thoughts have evolved. I've done a lot of work here - and even more with my sister and - yes - also with my abuser whom I have been talking with. I think that when we as victims blame ourselves, such blame may reflect a greater sagacity than the simple self-denigration we might otherwise assume. Only by accepting the blame can I ascribe to myself the power to grow beyond the insults I endured. My choice is really this simple - I either embrace fully my powerlessness, my victimhood - and hence I shall remain forever the hapless victim. Or I accept that I did something. I effected an influence on the route of the transgression somehow, someway. I didn't do it elegantly. I did not conduct myself with the stellar courage of a Captain Marvel comic book hero. I was flawed and dirty. But I did something, and changed the course of what was happening in some small way. Ultimately, it was enough to have someone call me her hero. I don't take that in the spirit of conceit. It is certainly not a bragging right, and you'll not see agent 007 employing my tactics. But sometimes it seems like that email she sent me is the only life preserver I have in the sea of darker memories and regrets.
There was simply nothing in how I subjugated myself that had any semblance of integrity or maturity. I was about to be Bar Mitzvahed and rise to the mantle of manhood - yet I was 85 pounds of barely pubertal child and looked even younger. I knew nothing of being a man. The incongruities of the boy I was, the submissive and essentially feminine role I was so frequently tasked to play, and the man I was expected to be - my whole life was about disconnecting and jettisoning entire parts of me. Nothing made sense. I stood on the bima of my own Bar Mitzvah a fraud, holding a universe of awful secrets in my head unknown to all but God Himself. He never swept in to save me or the girls - He only sat there watching. Judging. I've had my conversations with Him, too. They didn't always go well.
When faced with my abuse - the girls' abuse - I failed to assert a more noble will, but instead played on the abuser's field, engaged under his rules, dispossessed of the greater integrity this reflecting adult would rather imagine. And as soon as I was old enough, independent enough - I stopped looking back. It is perhaps easier to forget oneself than forgive oneself. How many others still don't look at themselves? Even more importantly, how many others never looked at us - for the same reasons? How many of us don't look at others? Think Jerry Sandusky and Happy Valley. Think the Boy Scouts, the rectories. Think how much was seen by heads that then quickly turned and stopped looking. I suspect many of us follow that same lead with ourselves.
Looking at one's past is not for sissies. Looking at the deeper truths is even harder. These are not pretty stories.
I was just a scruffy little kid with grass-stained knees holding the dirty secrets of our neighborhood no one else would see. I did all I imagine I could do. In the eyes of the boy I was, I was dirty. To at least one survivor, that boy was a hero. The former was necessary for the latter, and rephrasing it to appease sensibilities divests the truths I have learned to accept.