First of all, I've wanted to respond to this bruhaha, but I wanted to give it some time.
People feel what they feel. I know that what triggers me wouldn't necessarily trigger the brothers here, and vice-versa. I also understand that there are a great many trust and valuation issues each of us are going through and are at different stages in that. Sometimes, I fluctuate between them so I can't tell you which one I am at any given moment.
However, I think we need to think VERY carefully before we suspect anyone of being either less than honest or insincere.
We've all been hurt by the "Nao" incident, and as a result, are VERY sensitive when it comes to trust and believing the people we speak to are who they are. But, and please forgive me if this is insensitive to ANYONE here, but we have to decide whether we trust anyone who comes here or we're going to hold each other at arm's distance.
Let's face facts here. Any ONE of us could be lying about who we are. The mods (tanks guys and gals!) are very good at what they do, but someone can be THAT good that they slip through all the cracks.
In short, we DO NOT KNOW. WE don't know that we are what we say we are.
We have to trust that we are who we say we are until proven otherwise, besides, what's the point of coming here and being open?
This is very hard for me, particularly when you think about how I was hurt by being betrayed by people HERE, not just by abusers.
I may as well get this out in the open: Does anybody here think I'm lying about who I am?
Be honest. Do you? And if you don't, how do you know?
You don't. You can't.
And while I think that Nancy showed a little too much exuberance, and freely told her so, the fact that she feels unwelcome here is a shame, particularly since she came in and TOLD us up front that she was neither a survivor or a partner/family member of one.
Why would anyone want to be here? I can't rightly say. I know that there are sick people who want to reabuse us, or simply want a "thrill." But I don't think Nancy is one of those people.
I find it ironic that we have brothers here who commit viscious personal attacks and make baseless accusations of other survivors yet are allowed to remain and someone who honestly wants insight on surviving abuse and is willing to offer support is forced to leave BEFORE we see how she'll respond to constructive feedback.
Also, I'm a writer, I'm writing a book and freely admit this. Does that make me suspect too?
Truthfully, we HAVE to trust people until they are proven unworthy of trust. If you have suspicions, take them to the mods. That's what they're there for and they do a great job.
Now, as for the other argument, why is she here if she's not a survivor's partner or family? Well, I think Nancy's sincere in this too. It's nice to have a sympathetic "voice" on the outside. How many people who HAVEN'T experienced really want to know about it? None. And yet some complain that they NEED to become aware. I've made this statement countless times.
We can't have it both ways, people. We either WANT people to know and get to know about it or we don't.
We either have to TRUST until proven unworthy of it or we don't.
We have to believe the mods and admins will watch out for the real frauds and expose them, and report them TO THE MODS, or we don't.
Anyway, that's my two cents. Flame away!
Peace and love,
Scot